‘If you can find a melancholy in a major key, that’s when you’re really winning’

Photo by Chloe Ackers

The last time Say It With Garage Flowers spoke to UK soul, blues and R ‘n’ B singer-songwriter and guitarist, PM Warson, it was for the release of his second album – 2022’s Dig Deep Repeat, which he recorded in an industrial storage unit in Stoke Newington, north-east London, during the pandemic.

One of our favourite albums of that year, it was much harder and more raw than his debut, True Story, and was in thrall to the classic soul of Ray Charles and Booker T. & the M.G’s, but also paid homage to his love of ‘60s pop music and girl-group sounds, like Phil Spector, as well as vintage garage-rock and the surf instrumentals of Dick Dale, Link Wray and Duane Eddy.

For this year’s follow up, A Little More Time, Warson has explored those ‘60s pop inspirations, er, a little more…

“That’s always been there, but on this record I let the wider influences just come in a little bit,” he says, talking to Say It With Garage Flowers over a coffee in a café in the Marylebone area of London, one morning in mid-July this year.

There’s still plenty of blues and R ‘n’B on the album, though, but, as he explains: “It’s a lot more straight up, with some really wild electric guitar playing – those tracks are a lot rawer, alongside some more polished, songwriting-led productions.”

Warson chose to make the new record at Lightship 95, a floating analogue and digital studio moored on the Thames.

“The live room has a very distinctive sound and I think you can hear it at the heart of the recording – it’s quite a ‘roomy’ production,” he says. “It’s a great place to work – it’s like a mid-century spaceship.

“After doing the last album, I realised that I needed the room sound [in Lightship 95] for the stuff I was trying to do – I wouldn’t have got that in the other place. I was very specific with the engineer, Giles Barrett, that I worked with, about what I wanted and he really got it. I think you can hear that immediately on the opening track.

“We listened to a load of early ’60s pop records and Wish Someone Would Care by Irma Thomas, which was done at Capitol – it’s a big-room recording. It was a bit of that flavour… You’re not going to do it exactly like they did it, but part of this record was about letting go of the, ‘Well, in 1961, they would’ve done it like this…’

‘Part of this record was about letting go of the, ‘Well, in 1961, they would’ve done it like this…’ I just did it the way that worked for me now, but with some of that influence’

“I just did it the way that worked for me now, but with some of that influence on the process. I’ve always been someone who tries to let the process inform the sound, rather than the other way round, but sometimes it’s good to do it the other way round: ‘How are we going to get there? This is a good way of doing it.’ “

He adds: “The room in Lightship 95 isn’t massive, but it has got a high ceiling, and because it’s the hull of a ship, it has artificial walls. I wonder if that’s quite comparable to some of the buildings in the States that studios were housed in? It definitely has a similar resonance.”

To lay down the album, Warson was joined by his regular rhythm section, Billy Stookes (drums) and Pete Thomas (upright and electric bass), plus guests, including Stephen Large (organ and electric piano), Martin Kaye (piano), Jack McGaughey (organ), Ollie Seymour-Marsh (guitars) and Grant Olding (harmonica), as well as backing singers and a horn section. 

Q&A

Ahead of the album, you released a seven-inch single, Right Here, Last Night, which came out on FYND…

PM Warson: That’s my label. It was distributed by Acid Jazz and we had an arrangement with Légère Recordings, who are the rights holder and have done the album with me – they cleared the way for me to do the seven-inch. It was a reset for me, and that track was quite an interesting one to lead with because it’s not typical of the album – it’s more like some of my previous output. It’s late-night R ‘n’ B with a bit of a jazz sound.

I think it sounds quite Northern Soul, too…

PMW: Yeah.

And it has a moody edge…

PMW: Especially in the middle – it has a muted trumpet on it, which is very evocative. We did it on a whim – muted trumpet can be a bit naff, but we tried it out and it really worked.

The title track of the album, A Little More Time, is the opener, and it was released as a single digitally. It’s a dramatic, ‘60s-style, Phil Spectoresque pop song…

PMW: Definitely. It’s a sound I’ve had in my head for a very long time, and it was the first track we laid down in the first session, so it set the tone for the record. There’s acoustic guitar going all the way through it, and a nylon string guitar, and real, Al Kooper, mid-’60s Bob Dylan organ, which seemed to fit perfectly with the horns.

There were some tracks on the last album that had a Spector feel, like Game of Chance (By Another Name) and Out of Mind… 

PMW: They did, yes. but they were a bit darker. There are ten tracks on this album –  for the musicians out there, you’ll notice that nine of them are in major keys. That’s a big shift – the last album didn’t have a single track in a major key on it. The tracks were all quite dark and in minor keys.

‘There are ten tracks on this album –  for the musicians out there, you’ll notice that nine of them are in major keys. That’s a big shift’

Photo by Chloe Ackers

So, does that mean you’ve cheered up for this record? 

PMW: Yeah, but if you can find a melancholy in a major key, that’s when you’re really winning, so that’s what I’ve been trying to find a little more.

Over & Over, which is the second track on the record, has a late-night, bluesy feel… 

PMW: It’s quite a bold move to have that second – it was influenced by the Paul Butterfield Blues Band and the ‘60s blues scene in West London, as well as southern soul and Irma Thomas. It has my mate, Ollie, playing some very aggressive lead guitar on it.

One of my favourite songs on the record is Another City Night, which is very atmospheric. It reminds me of Under The Boardwalk by The Drifters and Spanish Harlem by Ben E. King… 

PMW: Exactly – those New York records that the British acts were emulating. It’s also got pedal steel guitar on it by CJ Hillman – he’s incredible. We’d been meaning to do something together for ages… Pedal steel is such a distinctive sound and evocative, but it’s often just shoehorned in. A lot of people want to put pedal steel on something because it’s cool… That’s fine, but I wanted to wait for exactly the right thing and it felt right. I sent CJ a message saying, ‘Now’s the time’, and he was game – he was very generous with his time

‘I’m a really big Dylan fan but I’m quite careful with how I approach his influence’

Photo by Chloe Ackers

There’s a great twangy guitar break on that song too…

PMW: That was me –  we overdubbed my Telecaster, which is my main guitar, because I was playing acoustic on that track. It was quite influenced by Little Barrie (Barrie Cadogan) – like a lot of guitarists, I’m really into him. He does those kind of bluesy but slightly cinematic things – they’re modal jazz and I’ve tried to tap into that in my own way, with a little bit of fuzz on the way in.

Closing Time really stands out on the album for me, because it has a West Coast, ’60s rock/pop feel – it’s slightly psychedelic… 

PMW: Definitely. I’m really into Buffalo Springfield, The Byrds, pre-the San Francisco hippy thing, and Dylan and The Velvet Underground. I’m a really big Dylan fan but I’m quite careful with how I approach his influence. I’d had the jangly riff for ages but it didn’t really fit in with what I was doing before, which was more jazz-soul-R ‘n’ B. Since it’s become more rock-pop-R ‘n’ B, it seemed to work, and I just reeled off a lyric which was just a load of nonsense really, depending on how you take it. I think that was the second track we put down.

I could imagine The Charlatans doing it… 

PMW: Yeah… I kind of let these things in… if I had something, I would throw it into the melting point. There was brief period with this album where I got a little bit lost because I had late-night R ‘n’ B, the slightly psychedelic thing, the ’60s pop, the country… It was starting to get a bit confused, but when I did the last session, which was Another City Night and  I Saw You In A Dream, it all made sense.

I Saw You In A Dream is my favourite song on the record – it’s a big, dramatic and cinematic ballad, with a ’50s, Roy Orbison-like feel… 

PMW: Yeah – I’ve been influenced by that stuff since I was a young teenager. It wouldn’t have gone on a previous record because it didn’t feel right.

There’s a twangy, melodic, Duane Eddy-style guitar solo on it… 

PMW: It sounds like it’s a baritone, but it’s in E on my Telecaster right at the bottom. The piano is also distinctive it’s a ’60s Wurlitzer, plodding along and doing almost a Beatles thing. It’s a bit unusual for me. We put a phase-shifter on the Wurlitzer, which gives it a throbbing quality.

The song, I Need A Reason, from the album, came out under another name, Every Day (Every Night), in 2022.  It’s like a bridge between the last album and this one…

PMW: Yeah – I changed the title. It’s basically a live cut not entirely, but fundamentally. We started doing the arrangement that’s on the album live.

The album finishes with In The Heights, which is one of the darker tracks, with a late-night / early-morning-in-the-city vibe…

PMW: Definitely – it’s more in keeping with some of my previous stuff, but it fitted well on this record. That track, Another City Night and I Saw You In A Dream tie-in with each other – they have a similar mood and imagery.

So, are you pleased with the album? 

PMW: I am. It feels like a massive step forward – both the production and the songwriting, as well as the playing and singing ensemble.

We do a lot of stuff from the last album live and I was very pleased with it, considering the circumstances in which it was made, but with this one I decided I wanted to do it properly and be less precious about other things. It’s the closest I’ve got to the vision for it. It’s not just emulating a sound – it’s a bit more infused with different things, and sonically it’s really close to the kind of stuff I like. I also like the package – the album cover.

Was the artwork inspired by a Willie Nelson record?

PMW: Yeah – it was. Kerstin Holzwarth, who did the layout, has a knack of doing something that’s very classic, but doesn’t look like it’s sending something up. It’s always a risk, but she got it perfectly. It doesn’t look like the Willie Nelson record, but it feels like it has the same vocabulary. It’s important –  the combination of the songs, the sound and the package… I’m really careful about album covers – I’m fussy and I take a lot of time on it.

A little more time?

PMW: Exactly.

A Little More Time is released on September 6 (Légère Recordings) on vinyl and digital.

https://pmwarson.bandcamp.com/album/a-little-more-time

‘I’m not a fan of very emotional singing. It’s more interesting to have a robot sing a heartfelt melody’

Usually found hiding behind a pair of dark glasses, Doviak is the mysterious and ice-cool multi-instrumentalist and producer who is best known for his work with Johnny Marr – he plays guitar and keys in Marr’s band and has co-produced the former Smiths guitarist’s four solo albums: The Messenger, Playland, Call The Comet and Fever Dream Pts 1-4.

In the past few years, Doviak, who is based in Manchester, has been releasing his atmospheric and often cinematic, electronic-heavy solo songs on digital platforms, as individual tracks or EPs. His music is inspired by ’80s synth-pop, electro, Cold War espionage – on his social media profile he calls himself cyberspace’s foremost purveyor of ‘Spywave’ – European travel, John Barry and gothic rock.

Say It With Garage Flowers had a clandestine meeting with him to discuss his solo work, his thoughts on new tech such as AI and immersive audio, working with Marr and why decentralised collaborations might be the way forward.

This interview will self-destruct in 10 seconds…

Q&A

Let’s talk about your most recent solo release –  The Vanguard EP.  It doesn’t sound as spywave as some of your previous material… 

Doviak: In my head it is, but in reality it’s not.

One of the tracks, Turn It Over, has a pulsing, ’80s electronic feel – it’s like Howard Jones… 

Doviak: Yeah – there’s all sorts of stuff referenced. Sometimes I’ll be playing around with a riff and it happens to be electronic and I’ll just go with that. I might try and make it something that you might even hear on the radio…

With a pop sensibility….

Doviak: That’s the idea. It’s fun doing all these mysterious tracks, but if nobody listens to them, it’s a bit demoralising. That’s not to say I’m doing things just to get radio play, because that doesn’t really work either. I like pop. To me, Turn It Over is trying to be an intellectual version of a really crass pop track. All of the lyrics in 90 percent of pop stuff are silly that’s what they’re meant to be and that’s why they sell, but if you like lyrics, they’re not very engaging. I like the idea of having that production but with something more quirky.

‘Turn It Over is trying to be an intellectual version of a really crass pop track. All of the lyrics in 90 percent of pop stuff are silly’

 

The Courtyard, which is on the EP, is darker and a much more cinematic track…

Doviak: It’s an electro-goth thing.

It reminds me of Depeche Mode…

Doviak: That comparison comes up a lot – people always say it. The funny thing about that is I never listen to Depeche Mode – I hardly know any of their stuff, but that’s what it’s supposed to be like – dark, low vocals, and moody with goth reverb.

There’s a song on the EP called Price of a Soul – I’m surprised Depeche Mode haven’t written a song called that…

Doviak: Yeah – trying to find any title that some fucker hasn’t used is almost impossible.

Wait For The World is an anthemic ballad – it has synths on it, but is more guitary and less electronic than some of your other songs…

Doviak: That’s right – the song dictated it. With some songs, there is a core tune – with melody, lyrics and chords – that you could play on an acoustic guitar, and it works in its own right, but with others, the production is so integral that it wouldn’t be much good on one. With Wait For The World I thought it was better to follow slightly more traditional instrumentation than a heavily electronic one – it just seemed to work better that way. It’s a really old song – about 10 years old. I just had to get it out eventually.

Would you say the EP is themed?

Doviak: Only because it’s electronic, but, also, because, in my head, the lyrics are about people’s relationship with the internet, social media and new tech. It’s this thing that’s been foisted upon us  – this revolution – and we’re learning how to navigate this world.

Are you a fan of AI in music?

Doviak: I’m not a fan of it but I recognise the fact that it’s not going to go away and its presence is only ever going to increase. It’s like better than the devil you know…

That’s a Kylie song…

Doviak: (laughs) Exactly – that’s a good reference… If AI is a tool that you can leverage to improve what you’re doing and make it more interesting then why not? I don’t think you should get rid of the human element, but some aspects of it will disappear. There will always be people who want that human element – I think that’s fundamentally why people like music. Anthropologists argue that singing is like bird song – it’s a way to show your sexual proclivity.

 ‘I’m not a fan of AI but I recognise the fact that it’s not going to go away and its presence is only ever going to increase’

Maybe singing evolved before language, but I’m not saying that’s the case… There’s an emotional element that connects with you for some reason – some people like certain genres – but some of it is more instinctive. That will always be there, but some people don’t really care about music – it’s just a thing in the background. They’re not going to care if it’s AI music playing in a coffee shop, but there are a hardcore group who will and they like real people… Some elements of pop aren’t just about the music you’re buying into the personality and the imagery as well…

I have no problem if you run an AI music program and you get an idea from it. If the whole thing sounds great and you want to put it out, whatever, but I think it will be a long time before that happens frequently.

What are your views on Dolby Atmos and immersive audio? Some producers see it as a gimmick – do the possibilities interest you?

Doviak: It is gimmicky but, again, it’s another thing that will be around… I don’t know if you know this, but Apple Music prioritise your stuff in their store if you have Dolby Atmos mixes…

Because they want to sell headphones…

Doviak: Yeah. It not’s a bad thing, but I don’t think it’s particularly necessary.  Look at how must people consume music – 70 percent of it is through a tiny, tinny speaker on their phone. Some people have amazing systems to sit and listen to, which is great, but that’s the minority…
I’m not against it, but it’s time, and how much time do you want to dedicate to learning how to mix in Atmos? If someone wants to mix it for me, great… I might look into it at some point, but it’s not a priority. I’m not against it.

You worked on a recent track called Ghost In The Room with a group called Moontalkers. How did that come about?

Doviak: It was straightforward – they just got in touch out of the blue and asked if I’d be interested. It seemed like fun and it was great to just do vocals on something rather than having to produce all the music too. Plus it’s interesting and fun to be working with younger musicians.

Your song Venus Eye Honeytrap was inspired by the story of Mata Hari, wasn’t it?

Doviak: Yes – that’s right, but the lyrics have their own subtext. I think she was accused of being a spy, but I don’t think she was probably. The song was actually more inspired by noodling around, but the overall aesthetic of it is just a distillation of the things I like – The Horrors and any slightly dark, gothic band, but I don’t like to stray into true gothic territory – it has more of a rock element.

It sounds like Gary Numan doing a theme song for a spy film…

Doviak: I think that’s a good description.

Your singing voice reminds me of Numan at times…

Doviak: On certain songs, it’s a deliberate choice to get more robotic than soulful. If I get the melody right and I have a very emotive piece of music with a tune that’s quite sweet, I want to upset that with something that’s a bit colder and dispassionate – to me it’s the right side of melodrama, because I’m not a big fan of very emotional and heartfelt singing generally. Sometimes it’s amazing, but it can get on your nerves a little bit… it just isn’t my thing. For me, it’s more interesting to have a robot sing a heartfelt melody.

Which is essentially what Kraftwerk did…

Doviak: Sure.

‘If I get the melody right and I have a very emotive piece of music with a tune that’s quite sweet, I want to upset that with something that’s a bit colder and dispassionate’

Alicia Vigil of L.A. rock band Vigil of War guests on Venus Eye Honeytrap. How did that come about?

Doviak: She’s a friend of a friend, who I worked with. I was in town, and we did some writing – we kicked around some ideas. Whether anything will see the light of day, I’ve no idea, but it was fun. I don’t do much writing [with other people] outside of my work with Johnny. I’ve done production and mixing, but not a great deal of writing.

Would you like to do more?

Doviak: Yes – that’s what I enjoy the most. The production and the writing are kind of tied together to some degree… I like it a lot more than mixing and engineering, which I don’t really enjoy. They all have positives and negatives, but the thing I really like is writing – it excites me the most by far.

There is an underlying Cold War theme to a lot of your solo music and it’s very cinematic. Have you written soundtracks? I know you’ve been involved with music for adverts…

Doviak:  Yeah – I have done, but not for a while. I’ve been too busy – there was a point where I was doing The Messenger album with Johnny and touring… We had a lot of production stuff to work out, because it was the first time we’d really gone out, and I was doing a lot of work for TV adverts. It started to take off, but I had to make a choice, so I did the live thing because it was more fun, and I got to see the world, play gigs and work with Johnny, which was great. I tried to do both for a little bit, but it wasn’t really happening – something was going to suffer…

Would you like to do film soundtracks? Some of the tracks you’ve done with Johnny, like Walk Into The Sea and Rubicon, are more like soundscapes than traditional rock or pop songs, aren’t they?

Doviak: Absolutely – that’s right. I like to have some sort of balance – if I was going to see a gig, what songs would I want it to contain? It’s nice to have a general thread of something running through it. Sometimes you want to hear a couple of up-tempo, catchy, straightforward songs with choruses, but then you might want a lull with some emotive stuff. Not everyone wants that – a lot of the audiences respond better to the up-tempo, catchy singles and they jump around and sing the lyrics – but I think they’re also impressed by the soundtracky stuff, and the people that like it really like it.

Where does your love of the Cold War come from?

Doviak: Probably from watching films. It’s not something I’ve always been into. I had a whole bunch of songs kicking around for many years, but with no real defining element to them, but at some point I thought it would be fun to do something John Barryesque – I’d liked Portishead and the idea of doing melodramatic orchestration. There are particular harmonies that are unique to that genre – there’s an element of melancholy. It’s not so much sadness, but more of a bleak melancholy…

Like Barry’s soundtrack to The Ipcress File

Doviak: Exactly.

Johnny and the band used to walk on stage to the theme from The Persuaders

Doviak: We did actually – that’s right. It’s a good piece of music.

Did you write your Enemy Numbers EP while you were travelling around Europe?

Doviak: Exactly – the impetus came from different places, and I liked the idea… If I’d had the budget, I could have done themed videos for the cities they were related to – Berlin, Paris, Hamburg, Prague… I had some brief ideas while I was on the road, but I didn’t have the time to expand on them until I got home. The emotion still remains – a set of chords and a simple melody, but that’s enough and it’s something to build on. If it’s the right thing, it sparks my imagination, and I can go back and build on it with that in mind. I’m lucky to be able to travel, and it’s a great way of doing it.

I see so many cities and I got to thinking what would it be like if you were a guy listening to a shortwave radio by yourself, in a room at night, with a different identity – it could be a strange, lonely experience. That’s why there’s a sadness to the music – slightly bleak and melancholy, but without being overly melodramatic.

Did you write Century in Montmartre, Paris?

Doviak: Yes – the chords and the basic tune. The idea is that there’s some guy in a room by himself, feeling melancholy and looking over the rooftops of Paris. It’s particularly scenic round there.

Do you have a home studio?

Doviak: Yes – it’s basic, but it’s enough for me to do what I need to do.

So, you record all your solo stuff there?

Doviak: Yeah, but Jack [Mitchell – Johnny Marr’s drummer] played on a couple of the early songs, Solid State Machines and Enemy Numbers, so we recorded his drums elsewhere. I’d do that again, but it hasn’t been convenient and for some of the recent songs it hasn’t really been necessary.

Do you have a big collection of vintage gear, like old synths?

Doviak: Not as big as I’d like – one of the reasons is because I have to travel so much and the other is because software is getting so good. Some of it sounds as good as the real thing – certainly by the time you’ve done various things to it production-wise and put it in the mix. We have a whole bunch of stuff in Johnny’s studio – a Juno, a Moog, a Yamaha SS30…

Johnny explored electronic music with Bernard Sumner in Electronic and then when he had his band The Healers he went back to more traditional rock, blues and psychedelic stuff. Do you think working with you on his solo records has made him experiment with more electronic sounds again?

Doviak: With the more electronic tracks like Spirit, Power and Soul, and Armatopia, that’s what he wanted to do – he already had those ideas. There may be one or two songs where I’ve said, ‘You could put a dirty Juno bass on there…’ or something. I can’t remember – he remembers that stuff brilliantly.

You’ve been putting out your solo songs and EPs digitally. Any plans to make an album one day?

Doviak: Yes – it’s a nice way of tying tracks together thematically and having them all released at the same time. From a more cynical point of view, it’s also better for marketing, or so I’m told – it’s easier to get more people on your side, like the press, if you’ve got a product out. I’d like to do it but my time’s limited…

Apart from during Covid, you’ve been so busy with Johnny’s albums and touring…

I know… and during Covid we were writing the last album, which has 16 tracks on it. We wrote about 20. In an ideal world, I’d have a situation where I could bang each of my tracks down in six months to a year and do an album. I think it’s more consistent that way.

What’s the process like when you and Johnny work on tracks together? Does he give you demos or do you both come up with ideas in the studio and layer stuff up?

Doviak: It’s kind of a mixture – we might have ideas for a song and once we start working on it, it can take twists and turns and end up nothing like the original – in my mind, the music is 75 percent Johnny, something like that… I tend to do more of the drums, the bass and keyboard stuff.

‘What if you were a guy listening to a shortwave radio by yourself, in a room at night, with a different identity – it could be a strange, lonely experience. That’s why there’s a sadness to the music’

Have you got a lot of unreleased solo stuff?

Doviak: Yes, I have. I’ve always written and recorded, and it’s 80 percent ready to go. That final 20 percent is a killer sometimes – you have to mix it and master it, and that takes a lot of time. It’s very beneficial to have another pair of ears on it. When you’re doing everything yourself, you’re very close to the song and you can’t see the wood for the trees. That’s where collaboration comes in handy. If you’re in a band, you kick ideas around in a rehearsal room… The one thing I don’t like about writing by myself is that it’s quite isolating and boring – I like being with other people, talking and having a laugh while I’m working.

I really like your song Don’t Follow – it has ‘80s synths on it and electronic drums. It reminds me of Duran Duran when they did The Chauffeur, as well as Howard Jones and Ryuichi Sakamoto…

Doviak: That one’s had a good response – mainly because I think it’s more of an identifiable genre.

It could’ve come off the soundtrack to Drive

Doviak: Exactly.

One of my favourite songs of yours is Russian Dolls – it’s very dramatic. Do you remember a ‘90s band called Rialto, who were influenced by John Barry and Ennio Morricone? It reminds me of them… 

Doviak: I remember the name…  I’d had the song knocking around for ages – the idea and a piano riff. It got tweaked over time – I struggled with the chorus – but it’s very John Barry / Ipcress File. It’s spywave, with almost Persuaders-like guitars.

Where did you grow up?

Doviak: In Cambridge.

There’s a spy connection there right away…

Doviak: Exactly.

Were you always in bands when you were young and how did you end up working with Johnny Marr?

Doviak: I was always in bands until I moved to Manchester, but I had a lot of friends in music, and I was involved with it. It’s a long story – I had a friend in a band in Manchester called Alpinestars, who said: ‘We’re going on tour – why don’t you come along just for a laugh?’ I worked as a guitar tech, which I’d never done. One of the guys in the band knew Johnny vaguely and we got in contact, met up and played some guitar – it went from there.

So, what are your plans for the rest of the year?

Doviak: I like the idea of working out a way of doing decentralised collaborations. I don’t even know what means yet, but it sounds good, and if you say the word ‘blockchain’ with it, people will probably think it’s interesting.  It’s if you have an idea and you put it out there online in some format – you could choose people to work with, or maybe anybody could do it and develop it in their own way.

And you’ll be doing another record with Johnny?

Doviak: Probably soon – he’s been crazy busy. It’s been nuts.

Follow Doviak on Instagram, X and YouTube.

For Johnny Marr tour dates and info, visit:  https://johnnymarr.com/